black holes and gray matter. in one thousand tangos.

U.S. Court of Appeals: Motorists cannot be stopped for giving police the middle finger

In a lawsuit against two police officers, the court held the insulting gesture did not constitute “reasonable suspicion that criminal activity or a traffic violation was afoot.”

The lawsuit was sparked by an incident that occurred in 2006 while John Swartz and his wife Judy Mayton-Swartz were driving to their son’s house. The couple saw a police officer using a radar gun to catch speeding motorists at an intersection. John, who was a passenger in the car, stuck his arm outside the side window and “flipped the bird” over the car’s roof. The police officer then followed the couple to their son’s home and stopped them. John was arrested for disorderly conduct after other officers arrived as backup.

The officer who initially followed and stopped the couple said he did so because John appeared to be trying to get his attention by waving his middle finger. However, the court didn’t buy that argument.

“[T]he nearly universal recognition that this gesture is an insult deprives such an interpretation of reasonableness,” Circuit Judge Jon O. Newman wrote in the ruling (PDF). “This ancient gesture of insult is not the basis for a reasonable suspicion of a traffic violation or impending criminal activity. Surely no passenger planning some wrongful conduct toward another occupant of an automobile would call attention to himself by giving the finger to a police officer.”

/ Show
  1. earthisalie reblogged this from guerrillatech
  2. miathangi reblogged this from truelifeimafuckingnormie
  3. truelifeimafuckingnormie reblogged this from kateoplis
  4. electeddevelopment reblogged this from jillusiveman
  5. politiciansoc reblogged this from shortformblog
  6. artisanandy reblogged this from kateoplis
  7. lockeinc reblogged this from kateoplis
  8. jillusiveman reblogged this from kateoplis
  9. vivathevoice reblogged this from kateoplis and added:
    I believe that our freedom of speech allows us to voice any sort of opinion about anyone, government officials included....
  10. mmilk-steak reblogged this from themagicalpurplemonkey
  11. lolzanity reblogged this from kateoplis
  12. 8intrepid8 reblogged this from kateoplis
  13. spilt-laughter reblogged this from replayingsun
  14. ediddy21 reblogged this from shortformblog
  15. politicaldame reblogged this from kateoplis
  16. intriguingsalsa reblogged this from shortformblog
  17. absolutezeronow reblogged this from replayingsun
  18. themagicalpurplemonkey reblogged this from swagandpassion
  19. a-zesty-lo0n reblogged this from kateoplis
  20. miadiamond23 reblogged this from kateoplis
  21. linda-muthafckin-cruz reblogged this from kateoplis
  22. cramulus reblogged this from elfboi
  23. unamericanny reblogged this from kateoplis
  24. pragmacattick reblogged this from kateoplis
  25. replayingsun reblogged this from shortformblog
  26. unsung1 reblogged this from shortformblog
  27. newsfeederlive reblogged this from kateoplis
blog comments powered by Disqus
©2011 Kateoplis