black holes and gray matter. in one thousand tangos.


What made me so overwhelmingly angry yesterday was the same thing that has been boiling in my gut for the last two years. When the federal government went after him – and MIT sheepishly played along – they weren’t treating him as a person who may or may not have done something stupid. He was an example. And the reason they threw the book at him wasn’t to teach him a lesson, but to make a point to the entire Cambridge hacker community that they were p0wned. It was a threat that had nothing to do with justice and everything to do with a broader battle over systemic power. In recent years, hackers have challenged the status quo and called into question the legitimacy of countless political actions. Their means may have been questionable, but their intentions have been valiant. The whole point of a functioning democracy is to always question the uses and abuses of power in order to prevent tyranny from emerging. Over the last few years, we’ve seen hackers demonized as anti-democratic even though so many of them see themselves as contemporary freedom fighters. And those in power used Aaron, reframing his information liberation project as a story of vicious hackers whose terroristic acts are meant to destroy democracy.

Reasonable people can disagree about tactics and where and when a particular approach pushes too far. Like Lessig, I often disagreed with Aaron about his particular approach to freeing the world’s information, even if I never disagreed with him about the goal. And one of the reasons why so many hackers and geeks spent yesterday raging against the machine is because so many people in power have been unable to see past the particular acts and understand the intentions and activism. So much public effort has been put into controlling and harmonizing geek resistance, squashing the rebellion, and punishing whoever authorities can get their hands on. But most geeks operate in gray zones, making it hard for them to be pinned down and charged. It’s in this context that Aaron’s stunt gave federal agents enough evidence to bring him to trial to use him as an example. They used their power to silence him and publicly condemn him even before the trial even began.

Yesterday, there was an outpouring of information about his case, including an amazing account from the defense’s expert witness. Many people asked why people didn’t speak up before. I can only explain my reasoning. I was too scared to speak publicly for fear of how my words might be used against him. And I was too scared to get embroiled in the witch hunt that I’ve watched happen over the last three years. Because it hasn’t been about justice or national security. It’s been about power. And it’s at the heart and soul of why the Obama administration has been a soul crushing disappointment to me. I’ve gotten into a ridiculous number of fights over the last couple of years with folks in the administration over the treatment of geeks and the misunderstanding of hackers, but I could never figure how to make a difference on that front. This was a source of serious frustration for me, even as SOPA/PIPA showed that geeks could make a difference.

So here we are today, the world lacking a prodigious child whose intellect scared the shit out of everyone who knew him. He became a toy for a government set on showing their strength. And they bullied him and preyed on his weaknesses and sought to break him. And they did. All for the performance of justice. All before he was even tried in a society that prides itself on innocent until proven guilty. Was depression key to what happened on Friday? Certainly. But it wasn’t the whole story. And that’s what makes it hard for me to stomach.”

Danah Boyd: processing the loss of Aaron Swartz

/ Show
  1. avengersdiscount reblogged this from kateoplis
  2. totalhermit reblogged this from kateoplis
  3. mellydraws reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic
  4. evillordzog reblogged this from kateoplis
  5. jimihands reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic
  6. mapa-eats reblogged this from kateoplis and added:
  7. cierralaboca reblogged this from kateoplis
  8. sad-eyes reblogged this from kateoplis
  9. nopressurecouk reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic
  10. macmankev reblogged this from kateoplis
  11. thelazylunatic reblogged this from kateoplis
  12. the-kirlian-observer reblogged this from bathtime
  13. deus-ex-musica reblogged this from kateoplis
  14. dignityindiscomfort reblogged this from kateoplis
  15. zackarooo reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic
  16. beedaleet reblogged this from kateoplis
  17. magicoftheforest reblogged this from kateoplis
  18. laneycr reblogged this from kateoplis
  19. ab-fucking-stract reblogged this from kateoplis
  20. beingasanemu reblogged this from kateoplis
  21. fire-starter reblogged this from apoplecticskeptic
  22. ifitseasy reblogged this from kateoplis and added:
    I find this entire situation incredibly said and infuriating on so many levels, the least of which is that those “not in...
  23. transpyro reblogged this from kateoplis
blog comments powered by Disqus
©2011 Kateoplis